Definitely LIBERTY! It's different, trendy, cute and fresh! I persoanlly like Liberty faith but I like Liberty over melody.
hey i think melody is a good name. melody means so. my sis name is melody. and she such a good singer and wants to play music instruments.
Melody is a good name. :)
LIBERTY!
Well I think you should name it Melody I think it is really sweet that your nan wants to have a part in naming your baby as long as you don't have a problem with it. You could always try for another baby and hopefully its a girl and name it Liberty or your could:
Melody Jean Liberty...
or
Liberty Jean Melody...
Good Luck!!
Tough One!
Melody is a very sweet name but I'd choose Liberty Jean 'cause:
1 - It's not very common.
2 - It's a very nice and meaningful name.
Melody
gosh i love that name so much :)
Melody.
It is the better name, but that's just my opinion.
I just think it's lovely that your Nan wants to name your little girl
so sweet
They are both horrible.
I like Liberty because it is different.
I would spell it different from liberty though maybe Libertee, Libertie, IDK
I really like the name Melody! You could spell the name Melodie is you want it to be a bit more different
When she gets older - do you see her as a "Mel" to her pals or a "Libby" ?
Melody most definitely. It's lovely.
Liberty is kinda trashy. Similar to Destiny and Desiree....
liberty melody jean
easy :)
everyones happy
Melody. It just seems classier than the name Liberty
i like melody better, liberty doesn't sound like a name, is reminds me of the statue of liberty
go for melody
I personally prefer the name Liberty rather than Melody. I think by giving her the middle name Jean after your Nan then you are showing your daughter and your Nan how important she is to you, which I think means more than having your Nan actually name your baby.
Oooh I'm with you on this one, Liberty is such a cool name and with the added potential of the nickname Libby.
You could go with Liberty Jean Melody or Liberty Melody Jean. That way your grandma has some input but you don't have to sacrifice the name you really love
Call it Liberty Melody Jean. Has a nice ring to it :)
I think both of the names are beautiful! Maybe you should name her Melody Liberty or Liberty Melody?
Or maybe you should explain that you do like the name Melody but you had your heart set on Liberty and ask her opinion on that name...if she likes it then you have her blessings.
i vote MELODY... but i think u need to see a baby to name it so ull know best =D... if u like both than theres no wrong answer just eeny meeny miney mo lol!
Personally, I don't like either name, but it would be nice for your nan to name your baby. You could always have another child a call her Liberty, but your nan may not still be alive then. I like the was Liberty Jean flows better than Melody Jean.
I like Melody better - I'd listen to your Nan
How about Elizabeth Melody or Melody Elizabeth, and call her Libby? Then you've got both your Nan's choice and something close to yours?
i like melody
Melody is nicer IMO!
but maybe Melody Liberty Jean
Both are lovely names, but I think Melody is gorgeous
Does your Nan know you are using her name as a middle name?
Try and talk to her, tell her you had your heart set on Liberty Jean..see what she says. If she still insists on calling her Melody (which is not a bad name!) then you have to decide whether or not you will...if you plan on having more children, you can use Melody or Liberty next time....
why not something like Liberty-Jean Melody, then everyone is happy
i personally prefer Melody, but you could have Liberty as a middle name and Jean, too.
So, Melody Liberty Jean, or Melody Jean Liberty.
use them both! like Melody Liberty Jean or Liberty Melody Jean,
I personally think Melody is better as a first as it sounds more classy.:)
Melody is a beautiful name. Not used too often but absolutely gorgeous!!!
It is completely up to you, obviously you want to please your nan but just dont feel pressured into doing anything you don't want to becuase you will regret it later. Both are quite pretty, but I couldn't say which was nicer as I can't decide. Just see which one your daughter (If its a girl) looks like when she is born. Or how about Liberty Jean-Melody (hyphenated or have as 2 middle names). That way both names are incorporated. Or Melody Jean-Liberty. But I prefer Liberty as the first name, slightly more unusual.
Anyway, congrats and good luck, hope the birth goes well
Alexandra~x
Liberty Melody Jean
Melody Liberty Jean